How Pain and Suffering Damages Are Calculated in Colorado Car Accident Claims

Posted On October 28, 2025 / By Manning Law / Car Accidents

In Colorado, pain and suffering damages in car accident claims are calculated using state law and methods that consider both physical pain and emotional distress. Courts may limit these damages, but juries and insurers still review evidence of how your injuries change your routines. Your Denver car accident lawyer can explain how these calculations may apply in your case and why they matter for the compensation you receive.

Table of Contents

 

The Basics of Pain and Suffering Damages in Colorado

When you hear the phrase “pain and suffering damages,” it simply means compensation for what an injury puts you through beyond the bills. Colorado law allows you to seek payment for both the physical pain and the emotional hardship that often follow serious accidents, including truck accidents. These damages matter because they recognize the struggles that receipts or invoices can never capture.

What Counts as Pain and Suffering in a Claim

Pain and suffering damages cover a wide range of non-economic losses after an accident. Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-102.5 places limits on these awards, but they still allow claims for physical pain and emotional distress. They may also include changes in how you enjoy hobbies or the routines you once counted on each day.

Think about sleepless nights or stress that lingers. You may also miss out on activities you once enjoyed, and the law allows those experiences to be recognized. These damages provide a way to show how an accident touches parts of your life that medical bills alone cannot explain. By including them, your claim shows a more accurate account of what you have gone through.

Colorado’s Damage Caps on Pain and Suffering

Colorado sets limits on how much we can collect for non-economic damages. For claims filed before January 1, 2025, the cap is $500,000 under Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-102.5. For claims filed on or after January 1, 2025, the cap increases to $1,500,000.

This means even if a jury awards a higher amount, the court will reduce it to the cap that applies based on when your case is filed. Knowing these limits helps you prepare for what a settlement or trial might involve. It also shows how Colorado applies consistent standards across cases.

Free CASE CONSULTATION

Methods Used to Calculate Pain and Suffering

When car accidents lead to pain and suffering claims, insurers and courts often rely on certain methods to decide non-economic damages. These methods are meant to turn real experiences that do not come with receipts into fair compensation for the trauma you endured. Here are a few of the ways these calculations are made:

  • Multiplier method – Your economic damages, such as medical bills or lost wages, are multiplied by a number that shows how serious your injuries are. For example, if your costs are $50,000 and the multiplier is 3, the non-economic damages would be $150,000. The number chosen depends on the length of treatment and whether your symptoms continue.
  • Per diem method – A daily dollar amount is assigned for the pain you experience and multiplied by the number of days you are affected. For instance, if the value is set at $200 per day and you feel pain for 180 days, the total would be $36,000. Courts and insurers use this to set a dollar amount for the time your injuries affect your routines.
  • Comparative verdict method – Judges and insurers review past awards for similar injuries in Colorado and rely on them as a reference. By comparing your situation with outcomes in other cases, they create a starting point for what damages may be worth. While every claim is different, this method helps provide a general range based on what has been awarded before.

The methods above are flexible, and no single formula applies to every case. Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-111.5 also allows damages to be reduced if you share some responsibility for the crash. You should understand these methods because they explain why outcomes vary and why pain and suffering calculations are not always the same.

Real-World Factors That Influence Pain and Suffering Awards

Every claim is different, but certain details often affect how pain and suffering damages are valued in Colorado. When you know what courts and insurers pay attention to, it is easier to see how those numbers might apply in your own case.

Severity and Duration of Your Injuries

The seriousness of your injuries makes a big difference in the value of a claim. In car accidents, broken bones or head injuries may heal with time, while some injuries drag on for months or even leave permanent effects. In truck accidents, where the force of impact is often stronger, injuries can lead to years of medical care that change the way you plan for the future.

Courts and insurers look at both how severe the injuries are and how long they last. If you are still in treatment years later or facing a permanent disability, pain and suffering damages are usually higher. What matters most is how long it takes for you to feel like yourself again and whether you are able to regain your independence.

Impact on Everyday Activities

Another factor is how much your injuries get in the way of everyday life. You might miss shifts at work or fall behind on family responsibilities. You may even stop enjoying hobbies you used to love. Simple things like driving to the store or climbing stairs can suddenly feel out of reach.

Colorado Rules of Evidence Rule 702 allows expert testimony to be used in cases like this. Doctors or vocational specialists may explain how your injuries affect your ability to work or handle daily responsibilities. Their insight helps courts understand what your day-to-day challenges look like beyond what your medical record says.

Emotional and Psychological Effects

Accidents can leave emotional scars that feel just as heavy as physical injuries. Anxiety may creep in when you get behind the wheel again. Depression can make once-simple routines harder to manage. PTSD may surface in the form of flashbacks or sudden fear.

These challenges are difficult to measure with numbers alone, which is why testimony and personal accounts become important. Your personal injury claim may include therapy or counseling tied to these struggles. Some claims also involve medication that helps manage ongoing symptoms. When jurors hear how these issues affect your everyday life, they are more likely to recognize the seriousness of what you have been through.

Pain and Suffering Damages FAQ

Many injury victims have questions about how pain and suffering damages work in Colorado car accident claims. These answers are designed to help you better understand how the law may apply in your situation.

Are pain and suffering damages available in every Colorado car accident case?

Not in every case. These damages are usually considered if your injuries cause physical pain or emotional distress.

How do courts enforce Colorado’s damages cap?

Courts reduce awards that exceed the statutory cap. For example, if a jury awards more than the law allows, the judge lowers it to the limit set under Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-102.5.

Can pain and suffering damages be part of an insurance settlement, or only jury trials?

They can be included in both. Insurance companies may take non-economic damages into account during settlement discussions, though they often dispute the amount.

Do non-economic damages apply if multiple drivers share fault?

Yes. Under Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-111.5, damages can still be awarded, but the amount may be reduced based on your share of fault.

Can mental health treatment records support pain and suffering claims?

Yes. Records from therapy can support these claims. Counseling notes or medical opinions may also be used to show how the accident affected your mental health.

Meet With Your Car Accident Lawyer in Denver Today

Important evidence in car accident cases does not stay available forever, which is why your car accident attorney in Denver with Manning Herington Accident & Injury Attorneys needs to act now to protect your claim. With a combined 100+ 5-star Google reviews, our team has shown how much Denver clients value our service and results. Contact us today so we can begin reviewing the details of your crash while they are still fresh.

Robert Manning

Robert Manning is a seasoned personal injury attorney and co-founder of Manning Herington. Since 2009, he has represented individuals across Colorado, focusing on achieving fair compensation for accident victims. Known for his thorough case preparation and client-first mindset, Robert is committed to helping people navigate difficult legal challenges.